Home | About Cathy Duffy | Contact Us
   

HOMESCHOOL REVIEWS
Parent Helps / How-To Books
Approaches to Education
Overview of Publishers
Early Learning / Preschool
Bible / Religion
Worldview
Phonics / Reading/ Literature
Composition & Grammar
Handwriting
Spelling / Vocabulary
Math
Math Supplements
Science
History / Geography / Cultural Studies
Unit Studies & All-In-One Programs
Umbrella Programs that Provide Curriculum
Foreign Language
Critical Thinking & Logic
Art, Music, Drama
Electives
Creative Learning
College and Career Prep
Testing & Special Needs
Catholic Curriculum

Physical Geography

by Arnold Guyot

American Christian History Institute

This is a reprint of the 1885 edition of this book. It serves as a companion to the section on teaching geography in James Rose’s A Guide to American Christian Education (American Christian History Institute). It is also quoted and referred to in Teaching and Learning America’s Christian History, although it is not required for that book. I am not knowledgeable enough to critique the geographic content of the book, and I assume it is accurate, although there are certainly more recent discoveries that would shed more light on some topics (such as earthquakes and plate tectonics.) When he ventures away from geographical facts, the content of the book becomes debatable. I am bothered by Guyot’s approach to"The Human Family"—the white Caucasian is held up as the ideal with every other race as inferior. He also makes a few generalizations about continents and historical movements that I consider to be more philosophical than factual. When reading Guyot, we must keep in mind the time period and culture from which he wrote, since some of his ideas seem out of step with contemporary thought.

This is a heavy-duty geography textbook. It is not very readable alone but would serve better as a source book. According to the publisher, this edition is the only textbook on physical geography written by a dedicated Christian and creation scientist in the twentieth century from the viewpoint that the earth and its geography are God’s handiwork. A supplement, Physical Geography Maps (American Christian History Institute) [$10], includes 36 maps with instructions and a sample full-color map.
Pricing and Purchasing

$9.95

 

   
Instant Key

Suitable for: those using the Principle Approach
Need for parent/teacher instruction: high
Prep time needed: minimal to moderate
Teacher's manual: N/A
Religious perspective:  Protestant but with soem troubling anthropological beliefs

Publisher Info

American Christian History Institute

PO Box 648
Palo Cedro, CA 96073
(530) 547-3535
www.achipa.com

Copyright 2009 - Cathy Duffy

Home | Updates for 100 Top Picks | General Book Reviews | Articles | About Cathy Duffy
Contact Us | Submit Products for Review | Ordering

 

Cathy Duffy/Grove Publishing

[Note: please do not call to order curriculum and other products that we have reviewed.
Contact information for the publisher and ordering is in the right hand column of each review.
Links to Amazon and CBD sometimes appear in the price information.]

16172 Huxley Circle
Westminster, CA 92683

 

Ecommerce Web Site Hosting by YourHost.com