Cathy Duffy Reviews home > Phonics / Reading/ Literature > Excellence in Literature: Reading and Writing through the Classics

Excellence in Literature: English I - V

Publisher: Institute for Excellence in Writing/Everyday Education, LLC
Author: Janice Campbell
Review last updated: May 2014
Instant KeyPublishers InfoPricing

American Literature

These five Excellence in Literature books guide students in grades 8 through 12 through self-directed study of classical literature. Titles of the five courses and the order in which they should be studied are:

Introduction to Literature
Literature and Composition
American Literature
British Literature
World Literature

Author, Janice Campbell wants to prepare students well for rigorous college work, so she directs them to do their own independent research and writing while reading each classic work. Truly designed for independent study, the only “oversight” is the requirement for a writing evaluator to use the provided Evaluation Rubric form to let students know how well they are satisfying the demands of each written assignment that is the culmination of the study of each work. Nevertheless, students would benefit greatly if they could meet for a once-a-week session with other students to discuss their work.

It is helpful if students have completed the Teaching Writing: Structure and Style (IEW) course from the same publisher, but it is not essential. While Teaching Writing: Structure and Style is not a prerequisite, students should have well-developed writing skills and a solid grasp of grammar and spelling. However, since some students might not have had much experience writing essays, Campbell includes seven pages of instruction on "How to Write an Essay" in the fore matter of each guide. For students who need additional instruction or practice with essay writing, Campbell recommends The Elegant Essay Writing Lessons by Lesha Myers. She also recommends Teaching the Classics: A Socratic Method for Literary Education if students lack prior experience with literary analysis.

All five courses are similar in their arrangement. In fact, the front matter up through page 47 as well as the format and models chapter and evaluations chapter at the end of each book are identical. The heart of each course is the nine modules or units for each course. It should take four weeks to complete each module.

Study of each literary work follows a similar format each month. Students select the version of the work they will read; specific recommendations, occasionally including an online version, are provided for many of the works. Campbell provides students with minimal background information within the guides. Instead, she directs students to numerous context resources that they are to explore the first week of each module. These might be internet resources (specific URL’s), other books, DVDs, audio resources, and even field trips that help students explore the background and author of the particular work they will be reading as well as history, art, and music relating to the historical era of the literary work. Most research will likely be completed online. Students should read through the assignments for the entire unit and select context resources that are most likely to be helpful as they complete all of their assignments.

Instructions for each module in the guide conclude with an Assignment Schedule with instructions for each week. Writing assignments vary from module to module. Students might write an "Approach Paper" one week, an "Author Profile" the next week, a "Literary Analysis Essay" the third week. Another module might assign the "Author Profile" the first week, a "Historical Approach Paper," the second week, and a "Literary Analysis Essay" the third week. Literary Analysis Essays will probably be the lengthiest and most-demanding of the assignments. A parent or "writing mentor" will use the rubric form to evaluate Literary Analysis Essays then students will revise and rewrite their essays during the fourth week.

Detailed explanations of the formats for each type of paper are included in the back of each guide along with samples of excellent student work for each format. Students also learn to use the MLA formatting conventions that they will need to know for college papers.

In addition to the guide and the books they will read, students must have a good dictionary, a thesaurus, a writer’s handbook, and a binder where they will accumulate their course work. It is expected that students will look up vocabulary words with which they are unfamiliar as well as grammatical and structural questions. A glossary at the back of each book defines literary terms used in the course.

Literary analysis in Campbell's courses focuses on deep reading and thinking rather than superficial comprehension. For example, one assignment for a Literary Analysis Essay in American Literature reads: "Write a 750-word essay comparing and contrasting the courtship strategies of Irving's characters, Ichabod Crane and Brom Bones, with Longfellow's characters, Miles Standish and John Alden" (p. 67). Students will need to have comprehended the details of the story to answer this question, but they also must think much more deeply to identify points of comparison and contrast in multiple works of literature.

Literary works are studied in a somewhat chronological fashion that is most apparent in American, British, and World Literature. However, you can use modules in whatever order you wish. In fact, you can even mix modules from the various volumes since the study format is the same for all courses.

In my opinion, most of the selected literary works are some of the most interesting and entertaining that might have been chosen, although some are certainly very challenging. Campbell's explains that her goal in selecting literary works was to choose works that:
- are foundational for understanding Western civilization and culture
- are classic works often alluded to in other media or in conversation
- tell the truth about life and consequences
- are particularly compelling
- offer a unique perspective on the culture
- engage readers and stimulate deep thinking regarding important issues
- are well written
- have endured the test of time.


Introduction to Literature begins the first lesson with a little more instruction and a gentler pace as students read six short stories and become familiar with the methodology. As students continue the course, they will read Around the World in Eighty Days, A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court, Jane Eyre, Pygmalion, “Legend of Pygmalion and Galatea,” Treasure Island, Animal Farm, The Tempest, and Gulliver's Travels.

Literature and Composition introduces students to Robinson Crusoe, Walden, The Count of Monte Cristo, Heart of Darkness, Till We Have Faces, Death Comes for the Archbishop, Julius Caesar, Ivanhoe, and The Importance of Being Earnest.

In American Literature students will study Benjamin Franklin’s Autobiography, a joint unit on Rip Van Winkle and The Legend of Sleepy Hollow plus works by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, The Last of the Mohicans, The House of Seven Gables, Moby Dick, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, House of Mirth, The Great Gatsby, and The Old Man and the Sea.

In British Literature, students will study Beowulf; Canterbury Tales; an expanded study of Edmund Spenser, Sir Gawain, and the Arthurian legend; King Lear; Paradise Lost; Pride and Prejudice; Great Expectations; Wuthering Heights; and To the Lighthouse.

World Literature uses what necessarily has to be a very limited selection of literary works to cover from the Ancient Greeks to the modern era. Works studied include The Odyssey, Antigone, The Aeneid, Inferno, Don Quixote, Les Miserables, selections from The Portable Nineteenth-Century Russian Reader, Faust, and Out of Africa.

The high school courses can easily become Honors courses if students read an additional book listed for each unit and complete an additional "Approach Paper" on that book. They are also required to write an additional six- to ten-page paper. At that point, Honors students should be prepared to take the corresponding CLEP exam to both demonstrate advanced proficiency and earn college credits.

While these are not specifically designed to be “worldview” type courses, Campbell sometimes integrates worldview type questions as she directs students’ attention in their study of some books. Campbell also recommends use of The Worldview Supplement to Teaching the Classics (the prerequisite listed above) to aid both student and teacher in exploring literature with worldviews in mind.

Students completing these courses should be miles ahead of most of their high school contemporaries in their ability to read and analyze literature at a sophisticated level. The challenging writing assignments also promise to develop student skills in composition to a high level.

Each Excellence in Literature course book is available in either print or digital (PDF) editions. Note that American, British, and World Literature are co-published by Institute for Excellence in Writing, while the other two books are published only by Everyday Education.

Pricing

  • All prices are provided for comparison only and are subject to change. Click on prices to verify their accuracy.
  • Excellence in Literature - English 1: Intro to Literature

    Excellence in Literature - English 1: Intro to Literature

    Excellence in Literature Content Guides for Self-Directed Study: British Literature (Reading and Writing Through the Classics)

    Excellence in Literature Content Guides for Self-Directed Study: British Literature (Reading and Writing Through the Classics)

    Janice Campbell

    Excellence in Literature Content Guides for Self-Directed Study: American Literature (Reading and Writing Through the Classics)

    Excellence in Literature Content Guides for Self-Directed Study: American Literature (Reading and Writing Through the Classics)

    Janice Campbell

    Excellence in Literature: World Literature

    Excellence in Literature: World Literature

    Janice Campbell

    Excellence in Literature - English II: Literature and Composition

    Excellence in Literature - English II: Literature and Composition

    English V: World Literature

    English V: World Literature

      Instant Key

      • Suitable for: independent study for grades 8-12
        Need for parent/teacher instruction: only to evaluate written assignments
        Prep time needed: none other than making sure resources are available
        Teacher's manual: N/A-student directed study from this guide
        Educational philosophy: classical, real books, college prep
        Religious perspective: Christian

      Publisher's Info