Before Austen Comes Aesop: The Children’s Great Books and How to Experience Them recommends literature for children, but unlike most other such books, Before Austen Comes Aesop is more narrowly focused on the best books through all of recorded history, what author Cheri Blomquist calls the Children’s Great Books List.
Beyond being a book of recommended literary works, it presents detailed instructions for making those literary works a useful part of your curriculum with options that range from reading the literature for enjoyment and edification through scholarly study that includes writing a footnoted literary analysis paper.
Blomquist believes that becoming familiar with the traditional Great Books is a worthy endeavor, but her concerns over a too-early introduction of some of those literary works prompted her to write this book and create her own list of recommendations that she believes prepares children for the later introduction to the traditional Great Books.
She explains the criteria she used for the inclusion of books on her list. She began with the qualities that apply to the traditional list of Great Books--qualities such as universal ideas and themes, contributions to the ideas that have influenced western civilization, layers of richness, and excellent craftsmanship. She added additional criteria of her own:
- The book has played a significant role in the history of children’s literature.
- It has influenced the development of Western literature—children’s, adult, or both.
- It has been valued by young people for much of its existence.
- It has long been considered excellent literature (p 15).
Blomquist’s resulting list is broader than one might expect. On the book flap it explains, “The Children’s Great Books list includes the classic works that, while not written strictly for children, were orally passed on to them for generations and are foundational for understanding Western culture. These works include Greek and Roman fables, myths, and epics: European legends, sagas, folk stories, and fairy tales; and the Bible. The list also includes the acclaimed works written specifically for children, beginning in the age of the first printing presses and continuing into the late twentieth century.”
Blomquist includes many contemporary titles that are highly regarded, acknowledging that they have not yet stood the test of time. On the other hand, she limits the list to books that have influenced the development of western civilization since she believes it is important that children (particularly those living in the U.S.) first understand the roots of their own culture.
Books are recommended for preschool through high school. Think of Before Austen Comes Aesop as an on-ramp that gradually leads readers into the traditional list of the Great Books. Blomquist includes some titles from the traditional list of Great Books, but she usually suggests a number of adaptations for younger readers from which to choose for any single work. This is the case with books such as The Odyssey and Gulliver’s Travels. In rare instances, such as with her listing of Robinson Crusoe, she recommends the unadapted book for teens who are ready for it.
The recommendations are arranged chronologically by the era in which the literary works were produced. She divides them into seven eras.
- ancient times through the early Middle Ages (1500 B.C.-A.D. 1000)
- the Middle Ages through the Protestant Reformation (1000-1620)
- the colonization of New England through the mid-nineteenth century (1621-1849)
- the First Golden Age of Children’s Literature (1850 to 1928)
- the Great Depression through World War II (1929-1945)
- the Second Golden Age (1946-1965)
- noteworthy Books of the late-twentieth century (1966-2000)
The Arrangement of the Book
After introductory information about how to use this book, Before Austen Comes Aesop is divided into two main parts: Part One and Part Two. Part Two is followed by a valuable set of appendices.
Part One presents the recommendations under one chapter for each of the seven eras. For each era, Blomquist identifies her top recommendations as either foundational (highest priority) or important (secondary priority). She arranges these recommendations in chronological order based upon when they were written or published. For each work, she lists the reading level as well as the interest level since some difficult-to-read books are great for reading aloud. For some books, she adds the line “Parents Cautioned!” to alert parents to potential issues. A description follows, although it focuses more on the work’s importance and why it’s included on her list than on the content of the work itself. If there is a caution, she discusses it here. She concludes each entry with another paragraph under the heading “Virtues and Themes.”
After the entries for the foundational and important literary works, each era has a more condensed section headed “Other Children’s Classics of This Era.” Here she lists many other books, also providing the reading level and interest level for each. Once in a while, she includes a sentence or two of commentary.
Part Two outlines three different approaches that might be used to incorporate works from the Children’s Great Books list into your curriculum: the Leisurely Adventure, the Book Club(ish) Adventure, and the Scholarly Adventure. Reproducible pages with instructions, lists, and forms are in the appendices.
The Leisurely Adventure offers two options, one slightly more demanding than the other. In either option, students will maintain a notebook where they record the title and author for each book they read. Under each title, they can write notes about their reaction to the book as they read. The more challenging option, designed particularly for students in grades six through ten, assigns one to five stars per book according to the length and level of difficulty. Students are to choose books with a total equal to at least 20 stars. They will maintain a notebook, write notes for each book, and keep track of the books they read on a log page.
The Book Club(ish) Adventure is exactly what it sounds like: form a book club, even if it consists of only two people. Add food and an extension activity related to the book. A few possible books full of inspiring ideas for extension activities and themed events are suggested as sources for ideas.
The Scholarly Adventure is presented for students at two levels elementary (approximately grades five through eight) and secondary (for high school). Both levels involve extensive activities for developing skills in reading, notetaking, vocabulary, literary analysis, discussion, and writing. While you can purchase study guides that walk students through the study of particular books, the ideas presented here can be applied to all types of literary works. However, this approach requires more work on the part of parents. Parents might select some elements from the Scholarly Adventure plans if they cannot have their students do everything.
The Book Club(ish) Adventure and the Scholarly Adventure might work especially well in co-op situations. However, the Scholarly Adventure also works for independent study if the individual parent has time to guide the student.
Before Austen Comes Aesop should be a terrific resource for parents who love the Great Books approach for classical education and want to prepare children for it beginning as young as preschool level. Children can gradually learn to appreciate and enjoy great literature rather than being overwhelmed by it.