Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind provides at least four years of grammar instruction for students in grades five through twelve. It teaches grammar, usage, punctuation, capitalization, and sentence structure. This flexible program has a unique design. The 388-page Core Instructor Text is a non-consumable book that is used for every year of the program. There are also four workbooks with companion answer keys that are titled by color: Red, Purple, Blue, and Yellow. Students will need one of these consumable workbooks for each year of study. (Yellow will not be available until 2021.) All of the books are available as paperback books or PDFs.

The Core Instructor Text has 130 lessons that are entirely scripted and show what the teacher is to say and do and how the student is to respond. The idea is that while you will work through the entire Core Instructor Text each year, using the same scripted dialogue and examples, students will use a different workbook with entirely new exercises each year.

The instructions in the foreword of the Core Instructor Text say that you should plan for students to complete four lessons per week. But it also cautions that lessons become progressively more difficult in the latter part of each workbook and that you should allow students to move at whatever pace works best. On their website, they explain that most of those who have used the program are not completing an entire workbook each year. Consequently, I would recommend to homeschoolers who are in the second or third year of this program that, after a summer break, they pick up where they left off in a previous workbook so that the topics at the end of the Core Instructor Text are not skipped every year. (This need not be done at the end of the first year.)

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind employs the same heavily-structured teaching approach that the Well-Trained Mind™ Press has used with other resources, such as First Language Lessons. This approach makes teaching easy, eliminating lesson planning or concerns about how to present lessons. The structure also suits those students who appreciate direct teaching and clear, detailed instructions.

Students can begin with any of the four workbooks, although the Core Instructor Text says, “Occasional exercises in the Blue and Yellow workbooks may have more ambiguity or challenge than the corresponding weeks in the Purple and Red workbooks, but this should not present a major challenge” (p. xii).

Students will memorize and recite definitions, rules, conjugations, and lists (e.g., prepositions). Sentence diagrams are introduced in the tenth lesson and are used as an essential teaching tool in many of the subsequent lessons.

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind is best used in one-on-one situations or with a small group since it requires direct instruction by a teacher and student responses. With a large group, it would be difficult for a teacher to ensure that all students are responding correctly as they work through the lessons.

Periodic, cumulative review is built into the lessons. The amount of review time increases as the amount of material to review expands. While initial review sessions occur on only one day of a week, an entire week is allotted for the ninth, tenth, and eleventh review sessions (weeks 28, 32, and 36 if you stay on schedule).

The workbooks each have about 600 pages. They repeat the rules and some examples for each lesson (but not the entire lesson script). The workbooks cannot be used on their own. The instructions in the Core Instructor Text often tell students what they need to do in their workbook. The bulk of each lesson in the workbooks consists of exercises that use sentences and paragraphs from fiction and non-fiction. Most of the exercises can be completed within the consumable workbooks, but students will need to do some of the exercises or writing assignments on their own paper or in a notebook.

Students will sometimes mark up sentences by circling, drawing arrows, or underlining particular sentence components or by using initials to indicate the roles of particular words (e.g., DO for direct object). Some exercises include sentence diagram forms already laid out so that the student need only write the words in the correct spots. However, some exercises require students to create sentence diagrams on their own, drawing these on paper or in a notebook.

As I mentioned, the instruction every year from the Core Instructor Text repeats, while each of the workbooks has entirely different content for the exercises. The instructions for the course do not advocate skipping the repeated instruction from the Core Instructor Text, but they tell teachers or parents to use their judgment as to whether to have a student complete all of the exercises. If a student obviously remembers a concept from the previous year and easily answers the first few items in the exercise correctly, it’s okay to not require the student to complete the rest of the exercise.

You might want to have on hand for reference The Diagramming Dictionary and The Grammar Guidebook, both sold by The Well-Trained Mind Press. All of the grammar rules and definitions taught in Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind, along with examples, can be found in The Grammar Guidebook, making it is useful for reference. The Diagramming Dictionary thoroughly explains how to diagram sentences, using example sentences from Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind course books. Both of these resources are available as hardcover books or PDFs. The Well-Trained Mind Press sells bundles that include the Core Instructor Text, The Grammar Guidebook, and your choice of the Blue, Red, or Purple Workbook with its answer key. However, it seems to me that explanations in the Core Instructor Text and workbooks are so comprehensive that you might have little need for these two reference resources.

Grammar for the Well Trained Mind is so thorough and provides so much practice that students who complete four years of the program should never need to study grammar again. A very generous six-week sample from the Purple Workbook is available to try for free.

Pricing Information

When comparison prices appear, please keep in mind that they are subject to change. Click on links where available to verify price accuracy.

Purple Workbook: A Complete Course for Young Writers, Aspiring Rhetoricians, and Anyone Else Who Needs to Understand How English Works (Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind)

Purple Workbook: A Complete Course for Young Writers, Aspiring Rhetoricians,  and Anyone Else Who Needs to Understand How English Works (Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind)

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind: Complete Purple Package

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind: Complete Purple Package

Core Instructor Text: A Complete Course for Young Writers, Aspiring Rhetoricians, and Anyone Else Who Needs to Understand how English Works (Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind)

Core Instructor Text: A Complete Course for Young Writers, Aspiring Rhetoricians, and Anyone Else Who Needs to Understand how English Works (Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind)

The Diagramming Dictionary: A Complete Reference Tool for Young Writers, Aspiring Rhetoricians, and Anyone Else Who Needs to Understand How English Works (Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind)

The Diagramming Dictionary: A Complete Reference Tool for Young Writers, Aspiring Rhetoricians, and Anyone Else Who Needs to Understand How English Works (Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind)

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind: Red Books Student Pack

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind: Red Books Student Pack

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind: Purple Workbook & Key

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind: Purple Workbook & Key
Get a FREE subscription to Cathy's E-Newsletter

My Lists

Save reviews to lists to guide curriculum choices. Register or log in to start your first list.

Instant Key

  • Need For Parent/Teacher Instruction: high
  • Grade Level: grades 5-12
  • Suitable For: family or small group
  • Educational Approaches: classical, traditional
  • Educational Methods: diagramming, interactive, memorization
  • Technology: PDF

Publisher's Info

Note: Publishers, authors, and service providers never pay to be reviewed. They do provide free review copies or online access to programs for review purposes.

Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in the post above are "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Regardless, I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255 "Guidelines Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising."